| DATE 03/28/2000 | The Clinton County Board of Commissioners met Tuesday, March 28, 2000 at 9 a.m. with Chairperson Hawks presiding. |
| INVOCATION, PLEDGE OF ALLEGIANCE AND ROLL CALL | Commissioner Scott Hummel gave the invocation. The pledge of allegiance was given to the flag. Roll was called and a quorum reported. Present were John Arehart, Richard Hawks, Scott A. Hummel, Larry Martin and Sara Clark Pierson. Commissioners Russel H. Bauerle and Mary Rademacher were excused. |
| COUNTY PERSONNEL | Ryan Wood, Jeanette Smith, Craig Longnecker, Tom OBryant and Annette Devereaux. |
| VISITORS | Warren Malkin, Elden Sillman, Lorina Sillman, Charles Horman, Jaunita Horman, Maurice Gove, Veronica Meyers and Tom Magsig. |
| MINUTES OF 02/29/2000 | The minutes of February
29, 2000 were presented.
BOARD ACTION: Commissioner Arehart moved, supported by Commissioner Martin to approve the minutes as presented. Motion carried. |
| CLOSED SESSION MINUTES OF 03/09/2000 | The closed session
minutes of March 9, 2000 were reviewed.
BOARD ACTION: Commissioner Martin moved, supported by Commissioner Hummel to approve the closed session minutes as presented. Motion carried. |
| AGENDA | The following items
were added to the agenda:
BOARD ACTION: Commissioner Arehart moved, supported by Commissioner Hummel to approve the agenda as amended. Motion carried. |
| COMMUNICATIONS | The following communications
were reviewed:
BOARD ACTION: Commissioner Arehart moved, supported by Commissioner Pierson to accept the communications and place on file. Motion carried. |
| ADMINISTRATORS REPORT | Ryan Wood, Administrator
gave the following report:
|
| PUBLIC COMMENTS | Veronica Meyers extended an invitation to the Commissioners to the Clinton County Farm Bureau Local Affairs Day Luncheon. |
| DRAIN COMMISSIONERS 1999 ANNUAL REPORT | Tom OBryant,
Drain Commissioner presented the Drain Office 1999 Annual Report.
BOARD ACTION: Commissioner Arehart moved, supported by Commissioner Pierson to accept the report and place on file. Motion carried. |
| ZONING | Gary Webster of Associated Government Services presented the following Zoning matters: |
| PC-07-03-2000 REZONE REQUEST BY CHAD COVELL IN SECTION 20 OF BINGHAM TOWNSHIP APPROVED | PC-07-03-2000 Request
to Rezone property in Section 20 of Bingham Township from A-2 General Agricultural
to R-1 Residential submitted by Chad Covell.
Chad Covell was present to answer any questions regarding his application to rezone. Discussion followed. Commissioner Martin noted that the Planning Commission has scheduled a public hearing for April to amend the language in the County Zoning Ordinance to clarify these situations. The language needs to be clarified as to the definition of the term adjacent. Mr. Webster stated that the Planning Commission felt that this particular request met the intent of the Ordinance and therefore, has recommended approval. BOARD ACTION: Commissioner Pierson moved, supported by Commissioner Arehart to concur with the recommendation of the Planning Commission to approve the request to rezone from A-2 General Agricultural to R-1 Residential. Voting on the motion by roll call vote, those voting aye were Hummel, Martin, Arehart, Pierson and Hawks. Five ayes, zero nays, two absent. Motion carried. |
| PC-05-02-2000 REZONE REQUEST SUBMITTED BY MOTZ DEVELOPMENT, INC. IN SECTION 4 OF BINGHAM TOWNSHIP DENIED | PC-05-02-2000 Request
to Rezone property in Section 4 of Bingham Township from A-2 General Agricultural
to R-2 Single Family Residential submitted by Motz Development. This issue
was tabled at the February 29, 2000 Board meeting.
BOARD ACTION: Commissioner Arehart moved, supported by Hummel to remove this matter from the table. Motion carried. Tom Magsig spoke on behalf of Motz Development. Mr. Magsig noted that it is their goal to help create ideal zoning situations. He presented what he felt would be their options, one being to request approval and then rezone the Walker Road frontage back to A-2 or the other to withdraw their request and submit a new application. Mr. Magsig questioned whether the County would allow the rezone to R-2, if the extra lots on Walker Road were excluded. Gary Webster noted that changes to the request would require this issue to go back to the Planning Commission. Discussion followed regarding the proposed plans and the Ordinance language. In view of the fact that the County Board cannot make changes to the request to rezone without sending the matter back to the Planning Commission, Mr. Magsig withdrew his request for approval. BOARD ACTION: Chairperson Hawks called for a vote on the motion to approve the request to rezone, which was tabled on February 29, 2000. Voting on the motion to approve, those voting nay were Pierson, Arehart, Hummel, Martin and Hawks. Zero ayes, five nays, two absent. Motion failed. |
| LANGUAGE AMENDMENT TO ZONING ORDINANCE REGARDING COMMUNICATIONS TOWERS | The Planning Commission
is recommending that Article 7, Section 7.2.4 Communication Towers and attached
Communication Antennas of the Clinton County Zoning Ordinance be amended.
Discussion followed regarding co-location, tower heights and distance between towers. BOARD ACTION: Commissioner Pierson moved, supported by Commissioner Arehart to send this matter back to the Planning Commission, following review by the Countys legal counsel of proposed language suggested by Mr. Webster to the effect that if it can be demonstrated that co-location on other structures can complete the applicants coverage area, the proposed antenna shall be co-located regardless of the distance between towers. Motion carried. |
| APPROVAL OF COMMISSIONERS EXPENSE ACCOUNTS | Commissioners
expense accounts were presented.
BOARD ACTION: Commissioner Arehart moved, supported by Commissioner Martin to approve the Commissioners expense accounts. Motion carried. |
| COMMITTEE REPORTS | The following are reports of Committee meetings: |
| PHYSICAL RESOURCES COMMITTEE | Commissioner Martin, Member of the Physical Resource Committee reported on a meeting held March 21, 2000. |
| AGENDA APPROVED | Chairperson Bauerle
called the meeting to order with additions to the agenda noted.
COMMITTEE ACTION: Commissioner Martin moved, supported by Commissioner Rademacher to approve the agenda as amended. Motion carried. |
| PUBLIC COMMENTS | Chairperson Bauerle requested limited public comments. There were no public comments. |
| DRAIN OFFICE FEE SCHEDULE | Chairperson Bauerle introduced Drain Commissioner, Mr. Tom OBryant, regarding a proposed fee schedule for the Drain Commissioners office. |
| PLANNING/ZONING CONTRACT SERVICES | Chairperson Bauerle
introduced discussion regarding Planning/Zoning Contract Services.
COMMITTEE ACTION: Commissioner Rademacher moved, supported by Commissioner Martin to recommend to the Finance and Personnel Committee approval to tentatively establish the Planning Director Position as generally outlined in the job description. Motion carried. |
| SUMMARY OF AGRICULTURAL AND OPEN SPACE COMMITTEE | Chairperson Bauerle introduced an Executive Summary from the Agriculture and Open Space Committee. Discussion followed. No action requested. |
| COUNTY PLANNING COMMISSION APPOINTMENT | Chairperson Bauerle
introduced a County Planning Commission Appointment.
COMMITTEE RECOMMENDATION: Commissioner Martin moved, supported by Commissioner Rademacher to recommend the reappointment of Ms. Stephanie Ward to a three-year term to the County Planning Commission expiring May 1, 2002. Motion carried. BOARD ACTION: Commissioner Martin moved, supported by Commissioner Arehart to concur with the committee recommendation to reappoint Ms. Stephanie Ward to the County Planning Commission. Chairperson Hawks called for further nominations. None were offered. Motion carried. |
| PUBLIC COMMENTS | Chairperson Bauerle requested limited public comments. There were no public comments. |
| COMMISSIONERS COMMENTS | Chairperson Bauerle requested Commissioner comments. There were no Commissioner comments. |
| BUILDING COMMITTEE MEETING | Commissioner Martin, Chairperson of the Building Committee reported on a meeting held March 13, 2000. |
| AGENDA APPROVED | Chairperson Martin
called the meeting to order with additions to the agenda noted.
COMMITTEE ACTION: Commissioner Arehart moved, supported by Commissioner Hawks to approve the agenda as amended. Motion carried. |
| PUBLIC COMMENTS | Chairperson Martin requested limited public comments. There were no public comments. |
| EXTERIOR SIGNAGE BID PACKAGE | Chairperson Martin
introduced discussion regarding review of bid package number 35, signage,
especially with regard to exterior signage.
COMMITTEE RECOMMENDATION: Commissioner Arehart moved, supported by Commissioner Hawks to recommend to the Building Authority approval to place the signage package out for bid, subject to approval by the County Administrator and Maintenance Supervisor. Motion carried. |
| LANDSCAPE BID PACKAGE | Chairperson Martin
introduced discussion regarding the Landscape Bid Package. The landscape
plan was reviewed.
COMMITTEE RECOMMENDATION: Commissioner Arehart moved, supported by Commissioner Hawks to recommend to the Building Authority approval to place the landscape package, with minor changes noted, out for bid. Motion carried. |
| CHANGE ORDERS | Chairperson Martin introduced the following requests for change orders: |
| VANDELLEN STEEL |
COMMITTEE RECOMMENDATION: Commissioner Hawks moved, supported by Commissioner Arehart to recommend to the Building Authority payment to Vandellen Steel in the amount of $34,971 for work outlined in Bulletin #12, with the necessary change order being authorized. Motion carried. |
| ITTNER-WIECHMANN |
COMMITTEE RECOMMENDATION: Commissioner Arehart moved, supported by Commissioner Hawks to recommend to the Building Authority payment to Ittner-Wiechmann in the amount of $1,696 for additional window frames not included in the quote when the doors and hardware were originally bid, with the necessary change order being authorized. Motion carried. |
| VANDELLEN STEEL |
COMMITTEE RECOMMENDATION: Commissioner Arehart moved, supported by Commissioner Hawks to recommend to the Building Authority payment to Vandellen Steel in the amount of $4,339 for an additional roof hatch ladder, repair railings on spiral staircase, move elevator beams and provide straps and deck for ramps, with the necessary change order being authorized. Motion carried. |
| VIDCOM AND
SHAW-WINKLER |
COMMITTEE RECOMMENDATION: Commissioner Hawks moved, supported by Commissioner Arehart to recommend to the Building Authority payment to Shaw-Winkler in the amount of $22,047.78 and VidCom in the amount of $330 for work outlined in Bulletin #17, with the necessary change orders being authorized. Motion carried. |
| SCHIFFER MASON CONTRACTORS |
COMMITTEE RECOMMENDATION: Commissioner Arehart moved, supported by Commissioner Hawks to recommend to the Building Authority payment to Schiffer Mason Contractors in the amount of $114.66 for cutting stone to fit the steel opening on the north elevation over the entrance, with the necessary change order being authorized. Motion carried. |
| SANDBORN CONSTRUCTION |
COMMITTEE RECOMMENDATION: Commissioner Hawks moved, supported by Commissioner Arehart to recommend to the Building Authority payment to Sandborn Construction in the amount of $6,600 for saw cutting the existing wall beginning 158" off the building, with the necessary change order being authorized. Motion carried. |
| HAUSSMAN CONSTRUCTION |
COMMITTEE RECOMMENDATION: Commissioner Arehart moved, supported by Commissioner Hawks to recommend to the Building Authority payment to Haussman Construction in the amount of $1,842.50 for additional lockers, with the necessary change order being authorized. Motion carried. |
| SANDBORN CONSTRUCTION |
Sandborn Construction repairs to the existing drainage structures per the City of St. Johns letter dated 9/21/99. Sandborn Construction excavation and backfill for the new telephone conduit. COMMITTEE RECOMMENDATION: Commissioner Hawks moved, supported by Commissioner Arehart to recommend to the Building Authority payment to Sandborn Construction in the amount of $440 for water service to the museum and fixing a water leak in the street, payment in the amount of $3,100 for repairs to existing drainage structures, payment in the amount of $1,240 for excavation and backfill for the new telephone conduit, with the necessary change orders being authorized. Motion carried. |
| SCHIFFER MASON CONTRACTORS |
|
| SANDBORN CONSTRUCTION |
COMMITTEE RECOMMENDATION: Commissioner Hawks moved, supported by Commissioner Arehart to recommend to the Building Authority payment to Sandborn Construction in the amount of $1,876 for additional drainage structures per Bulletin #12, with the necessary change order being authorized. Motion carried. |
| OTIS ELEVATOR |
COMMITTEE RECOMMENDATION: Commissioner Arehart moved, supported by Commissioner Hawks to recommend to the Building Authority payment to Otis Elevator in the amount of $1,920 for re-working the ramshead rail brackets, with the necessary change order being authorized. Motion carried. |
| SCHIFFER MASON CONTRACTORS |
COMMITTEE RECOMMENDATION: Commissioner Arehart moved, supported by Commissioner Hawks to recommend to the Building Authority charging $1,920 to Schiffer Mason Contractors, due to misalignment of the elevator shaft, with the necessary change order authorized. Motion carried. |
| SHAW-WINKLER |
COMMITTEE RECOMMENDATION: Commissioner Hawks moved, supported by Commissioner Arehart to recommend to the Building Authority payment to Shaw-Winkler in the amount of $512.77 for installing the fuel oil piping, with the necessary change order being authorized. Motion carried. |
| LANSING ELECTRIC MOTORS |
COMMITTEE RECOMMENDATION: Commissioner Arehart moved, supported by Commissioner Hawks to recommend to the Building Authority payment to Lansing Electric Motors in the amount of $553 and payment to GTE in the amount of $710 for additional work described in Bulletin #18, with the necessary change orders being authorized. Motion carried. |
| GTE NETWORK UPGRADE | Chairperson Martin
introduced discussion regarding the GTE Network Upgrade.
COMMITTEE RECOMMENDATION: Commissioner Arehart moved, supported by Commissioner Hawks to recommend payment to GTE in the amount of $44,073.45 for a network upgrade, with funding coming from the Construction Fund. Motion carried. BOARD ACTION: Commissioner Martin moved, supported by Commissioner Arehart to concur with the committee recommendation. Motion carried. |
| BULLETIN #21 | Chairperson Martin
introduced review of Bulletin #21 for a budgeted amount of $55,000. This
bulletin has been issued to contractors for quotation.
COMMITTEE RECOMMENDATION: Commissioner Arehart moved, supported by Commissioner Hawks to recommend to the Building Authority having Clark Construction proceed on time and material for work described in Bulletin #21, with a not to exceed number furnished at the next meeting. Motion carried. |
| NEW TRAFFIC SIGNAL, SHELVING AND WIRE MESH PARTITIONS | Chairperson Martin
introduced information regarding the new traffic signal, wire mesh partitions
and shelving. These bid package quotes were received on March 10, 2000.
Clark Construction recommends the low bidders as follows:
COMMITTEE RECOMMENDATION: Commissioner Hawks moved, supported by Commissioner Arehart to recommend to the Building Authority the low bidder for the new traffic signals awarded to John R. Howell, Inc. Dimondale at a cost of $41,880. Motion carried. COMMITTEE RECOMMENDATION: Commissioner Hawks moved, Commissioner Arehart to recommend to the Building Authority the low bidder for shelving awarded to The Casper Corporation at a cost of $43,541.60, using the alternate bid using wood inserts for heavy duty units. Motion carried. COMMITTEE RECOMMENDATION: Commissioner Arehart moved, supported by Commissioner Hawks to recommend to the Building Authority the low bidder for wire mesh partitions to Rayhaven Equipment Company at a cost of $19,046. Motion carried. |
| CLARK CONSTRUCTION MONTHLY REPORT | Chairperson Martin
introduced the monthly report for February, 2000 from Clark Construction.
Discussion regarding weather conditions, demolition of the Administrative
Building (Old Jail), and construction schedule were discussed.
|
| TRANSACTION DRAWER FOR 911 | Chairperson Martin introduced review of a quotation submitted by Haussman Construction for the purchase and installation of a Transaction drawer in the 911 area at a cost of $4,600. Clark Construction will be seeking additional bids for this item. No action taken. |
| MOVING BID PACKAGE | Chairperson Martin
introduced discussion regarding the Moving Bid Package Bids received. Clark
Construction recommends that the low bidder, Allied Office Interiors be
awarded the bid at a cost of $21,200.
COMMITTEE RECOMMENDATION: Commissioner Arehart moved, supported by Commissioner Hawks to recommend to the Building Authority to award the Moving Bid Package contract to Allied Office Interiors in the amount of $21,220 for the moving portion of this project. Motion carried. |
| BULLETIN #20 | Chairperson Martin
introduced discussion regarding Bulletin #20, which includes revised snow
melt for the State Street entrance, and also includes site lighting, cupola
lighting, clock illumination and flagpole lights. Clark recommends that
this work be completed on a time and material basis with a cost not to exceed
$47,080. Clark requests items to be approved in principal, with final cost
to be presented at the completion of items.
COMMITTEE RECOMMENDATION: Commissioner Hawks moved, supported by Commissioner Arehart to recommend to the Building Authority that work described in Bulletin #20 be completed on a time and material basis, except for 1E, with a cost not to exceed $47,115. Motion carried |
| PURCHASE OF FOUNTAIN EQUIPMENT | Chairperson Martin
introduced an updated quotation for the fountain equipment in the amount
of $20,300.
COMMITTEE RECOMMENDATION: Commissioner Arehart moved, supported by Commissioner Hawks to recommend to the Building Authority approval of the purchase of fountain equipment at a cost of $20,300. Motion carried. |
| BID PACKAGE FOR INTERIOR SIGNAGE | Chairperson Martin
introduced discussion regarding interior signage. Specifications have been
received with the budget amount for this bid package at $25,000.
COMMITTEE RECOMMENDATION: Commissioner Arehart moved, supported by Commissioner Hawks to recommend to the Building Authority approval to proceed for bidding the interior signage package. Motion carried. |
| PUBLIC COMMENTS | Chairperson Martin requested limited public comments. There were no public comments. |
| COMMISSIONERS COMMENTS | Chairperson Martin introduced Commissioner comments. There were no Commissioner comments. |
| BUILDING COMMITTEE MEETING | Commissioner Martin, Chairperson of the Building Committee reported on a meeting held March 27, 2000. |
| AGENDA APPROVED | Chairperson Martin
called the meeting to order.
COMMITTEE ACTION: Commissioner Arehart moved, supported by Commissioner Hawks to approve the agenda. Motion carried. |
| PUBLIC COMMENTS | Chairperson Martin requested limited public comments. There were no public comments. |
| LANDSCAPE DESIGN PRESENTED | Chairperson Martin introduced Mr. Mark Robinson, Landscape Architect, regarding the landscape design for the courthouse. Mr. Robinson requested any questions and concerns by the Committee, along with approval to proceed with the proposed landscape design. The placement of the Veterans Memorials on the Courthouse grounds were reviewed. The Administrator will contact the Veterans regarding their questions. Mr. Wood, Administrator, questioned the irrigation plan for the courthouse grounds. The Landscape Architect requested review of the irrigation plan to adapt to the landscape design. |
| LANDSCAPE AND FOUNTAIN DESIGN APPROVED | Chairperson Martin
introduced Mr. Ivars (Buzz) Dzirnis, Architect, regarding a brief overview
of the final fountain drawings.
COMMITTEE RECOMMENDATION: Commissioner Arehart moved, supported by Commissioner Hawks to recommend to the Building Authority approval of the fountain and landscape design as presented by the Architects. Motion carried. |
| CHANGE ORDERS | Chairperson Martin introduced the following recommended requests for change orders from Clark Construction: |
| NATIONAL COATINGS, INC. | National Coatings,
Inc. a quotation for painting the north and south canopies.
COMMITTEE RECOMMENDATION: Commissioner Arehart moved, supported by Commissioner Hawks to recommend to the Building Authority payment to National Coatings, Inc. in the amount of $2,800 for painting the north and south canopies, with the necessary change order being authorized. Motion carried. |
| SANDBORN CONSTRUCTION | Sandborn Construction
a quotation for installing a 1500 gallon septic tank.
COMMITTEE RECOMMENDATION: Commissioner Arehart moved, supported by Commissioner Hawks to recommend to the Building Authority payment to Sandborn Construction in the amount of $3,600 for installing a 1500 gallon septic tank, with the necessary change order being authorized. Motion carried. |
| SHAW-WINKLER | Shaw-Winkler
a quotation for Bulletin #20 (snow melt revision)
COMMITTEE RECOMMENDATION: Commissioner Arehart moved, supported by Commissioner Hawks to recommend to the Building Authority payment to Shaw-Winkler in the amount of $8,393.77 for a snow melt revision, with the necessary change order being authorized. Motion carried. |
| ITTNER-WIECHMANN | Ittner-Wiechmann
a quotation as outlined in Bulletin #22.
COMMITTEE RECOMMENDATION: Commissioner Hawks moved, supported by Commissioner Arehart to recommend to the Building Authority payment to Ittner-Wiechmann in the amount of $678 for work outlined in Bulletin #22, with the necessary change order being authorized. Motion carried. |
| SHAW-WINKLER | Shaw-Winkler
a quotation for additional costs for insulation due to changes from
original bid drawings.
COMMITTEE RECOMMENDATION: Commissioner Arehart moved, supported by Commissioner Hawks to recommend to the Building Authority payment to Shaw-Winkler in the amount of $1,271.18 for additional costs for insulation, with the necessary change order being authorized. Motion carried. |
| SHAW-WINKLER | Shaw-Winkler
a quotation for Bulletin #22.
COMMITTEE RECOMMENDATION: Commissioner Arehart moved, supported by Commissioner Hawks to recommend to the Building Authority payment to Shaw-Winkler in the amount of $4,901.22 for elevator room exhaust described in Bulletin #22, with the necessary change order being authorized. Motion carried. |
| ALLIED OFFICE INTERIORS | Allied Office
Interiors additional furniture requested.
COMMITTEE RECOMMENDATION: Commissioner Arehart moved, supported by Commissioner Hawks to recommend to the Building Authority payment to Allied Office Interiors in the amount of $6,109.87 for additional furniture requested, with the necessary change order being authorized. Motion carried. |
| VANDELLEN STEEL | VanDellen Steel
a revised quotation for Bulletin #12 per Clarks letter dated
3/3/00.
COMMITTEE RECOMMENDATION: Commissioner Hawks moved, supported by Commissioner Arehart to recommend to the Building Authority payment to VanDellen Steel in the amount of $6,465 for anodized aluminum in lieu of painted galvanized steel, with the necessary change order being authorized. Motion carried. |
| SHAW-WINKLER | Shaw-Winkler
a quotation for installing a mixing valve on the domestic hot water
line and a hand held shower wand with slide bar and vacuum breaker for one
shower stall.
COMMITTEE RECOMMENDATION: Commissioner Arehart moved, supported by Commissioner Hawks to recommend to the Building Authority payment to Shaw-Winkler in the amount of $1,570 for this change, using the 85 degree to 140 degrees F valve, with the necessary change order being authorized. Motion carried. |
| NATIONAL COATINGS | National Coatings
a quotation for painting the revised election supply area.
COMMITTEE RECOMMENDATION: Commissioner Hawks moved, supported by Commissioner Arehart to recommend to the Building Authority payment to National Coatings in the amount of $155 for painting the revised election supply area, with the necessary change order authorized. Motion carried. |
| SCHEDULE FOR FINAL ELEVATOR INSPECTIONS | Chairperson Martin introduced correspondence from Otis Elevator submitting a schedule for final elevator inspections. No action is requested. |
| CONSTRUCTION OVERTIME AUTHORIZED, IF NECESSARY | Chairperson Martin
introduced discussion regarding the finalization of the project. Mr. Randy
Jobin, Clark Construction, suggested having the option of spending between
$8,000 - $10,000 for overtime to guarantee having the final project completed
on time. Mr. Waldrop stated that hopefully they will not need to use overtime.
COMMITTEE RECOMMENDATION: Commissioner Hawks moved, supported by Commissioner Arehart to recommend to the Building Authority approval to Clark Construction spending up to $10,000 for overtime, to assist in completing additional work, subject to approval by the County Administrator. Motion carried. |
| LANSING ELECTRIC MOTORS BULLETIN #21 | Chairperson Martin
introduced a quotation from Lansing Electric Motors for work described in
Bulletin #21. The Construction Manager recommends authorizing Bulletin #21
to be completed on a time and material basis, not to exceed $58,970.
COMMITTEE RECOMMENDATION: Commissioner Arehart moved, supported by Commissioner Martin to recommend to the Building Authority to authorize Bulletin #21 to be completed on time and material basis, not to exceed $58,970. Motion carried. |
| SHAW-WINKLER
RELOCATE FVAV-3-30 |
Chairperson Martin introduced information received regarding Shaw-Winkler being directed to relocate FVAV-3-30 as a result of a walk through that took place on February 17, 2000. This work is to be performed on a time and material basis. No action requested. |
| 911 CENTER ADDITIONAL WORK | Chairperson Martin
introduced additional work for the 911 center.
COMMITTEE RECOMMENDATION: Commissioner Hawks moved, supported by Commissioner Arehart to recommend to the Building Authority to authorize the following work to be completed on a time and material basis: Motion carried.
|
| JUVENILE COURT BUILDING | Chairperson Martin introduced correspondence received regarding the Juvenile Court building. No action taken. |
| APPLIANCES FOR BREAKROOMS IN NEW COURTHOUSE | Chairperson Martin
introduced correspondence from Administrator Wood regarding appliances for
the courthouse. It is suggested to authorize bidding of appliances for lunch
rooms in the courthouse.
COMMITTEE RECOMMENDATION: Commissioner Arehart moved, supported by Commissioner Hawks to recommend to the Building Authority authorizing the bidding of appliances for lunch rooms in the courthouse. Motion carried. |
| MCCONNELL STREET PARKING LOT | Chairperson Martin introduced discussion regarding the resurfacing and striping of McConnell Street parking lot. The budgeted amount for this work is $15,000. Administrator Wood will meet with the St. Johns School Board tonight to review the work on the parking lot. |
| BULLETIN BOARDS FOR NEW BUILDING | Chairperson Martin introduced correspondence received from Court Administrator, Jeanette Huard, regarding bulletin boards for the Circuit and Family Courtrooms. The Architect is including bulletin boards in the signage package. |
| CLARIFICATION OF BUILDING CONCERNS | Chairperson Martin
introduced Mr. John Meyer, Architect. The following concerns were clarified:
|
| PUBLIC COMMENTS | Chairperson Martin requested limited public comments. There were no public comments. |
| COMMISSIONERS COMMENTS | Chairperson Martin requested Commissioner comments. There were no Commissioner comments. |
| FINANCE & PERSONNEL COMMITTEE MEETING | Commissioner Pierson, Finance Chairperson and Commissioner Arehart, Personnel Chairperson reported on a Finance and Personnel Committee meeting held March 9, 2000. |
| AGENDA APPROVED | Chairperson Pierson
called the meeting to order with additions to the agenda noted.
COMMITTEE ACTION: Commissioner Bauerle moved, supported by Commissioner Hummel to approve the revised agenda. Motion carried. |
| PUBLIC COMMENTS | Chairperson Pierson requested limited public comments. There were no public comments. |
| CLOSED SESSION REGARDING OLIVE TREE LAWSUIT | Chairperson Pierson
requested a motion to adjourn to Executive Session regarding the Olive Tree
Lawsuit.
COMMITTEE ACTION: Commissioner Arehart moved, supported by Commissioner Hummel to recommend proceeding to closed session to discuss the pending Olive Tree lawsuit. A roll call vote was taken. Motion carried unanimously. COMMITTEE ACTION: Commissioner Hummel moved, supported by Commissioner Arehart to recommend proceeding to open session. A roll call vote was taken. Motion carried unanimously. Commissioner Rademacher asked the value of Comprehensive Plans for townships. Attorney Fahey noted Comprehensive Plans are a good means of planning for future areas that may be mobile home parks. |
| APPOINTMENT OF JOHN AREHART TO ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT CORPORATION | Chairperson Pierson
introduced discussion regarding the expiration of the term of John Arehart
as member to the Economic Development Corporation on April 12, 2000.
COMMITTEE RECOMMENDATION: Commissioner Bauerle moved, supported by Commissioner Martin to recommend the reappointment of Mr. John Arehart to the Economic Development Corporation, six-year term expiring on April 12, 2006. Motion carried. BOARD ACTION: Commissioner Pierson moved, supported by Commissioner Hummel to concur with the Committee recommendation to reappoint John Arehart to the Economic Development Corporation. Chairperson Hawks called for further nominations. None were offered. Motion carried. |
| COSTS ASSOCIATED WITH DISTRICT COURT FIRE | Chairperson Pierson
introduced a request from Administration to adjust the account for payment
and insurance reimbursement for repairs to fire damaged 65th
District Court building.
COMMITTEE RECOMMENDATION: Commissioner Arehart moved, supported by Commissioner Rademacher to recommend increasing insurance reimbursement (101-25300-679000) by $11,387.48 and increasing insurance expenses (101-86500-830000) by $11,387.48 for repairs noted above. Motion carried. BOARD ACTION: Commissioner Pierson moved, supported by Commissioner Martin to concur with the Committee recommendation. Motion carried. |
| SHERIFF
INKLESS FINGERPRINT GRANT |
Chairperson Pierson
introduced a request to apply for an Inkless Fingerprint Grant from Jail
Administrator Vetter. The block grant is a 10% match, one time grant from
the Federal Office of Criminal Justice. It is being funded through the State
Office of Drug Control Policy. Administration supports the request.
COMMITTEE ACTION: Commissioner Arehart moved, supported by Commissioner Martin to authorize the Sheriffs Office to apply for Inkless Fingerprint Grant, with the Chairperson signing on behalf of the entire Board of Commissioners. Motion carried. |
| HEALTH DEPARTMENT AND RESA SPACE | Chairperson Pierson introduced discussion regarding space usage for the Health Department and RESA. The Administrator questioned whether any other groups may be interested in space. It was noted that the Clinton Conservation District will remain at their present location. |
| PUBLIC COMMENTS | Chairperson Pierson introduced limited public comments. There were no public comments. |
| COMMISSIONERS COMMENTS | Chairperson Pierson
requested Commissioner comments.
|
| FINANCE & PERSONNEL COMMITTEE MEETING | Commissioner Pierson, Finance Chairperson and Commissioner Arehart, Personnel Chairperson reported on a Finance and Personnel Committee meeting held March 16, 2000. |
| AGENDA APPROVED | Chairperson Pierson
called the meeting to order.
COMMITTEE ACTION: Commissioner Bauerle moved, supported by Commissioner Rademacher to approve the agenda as printed. Motion carried. |
| PUBLIC COMMENTS | Chairperson Pierson introduced limited public comments. There were no public comments. |
| COMMUNICATIONS RECEIVED | Chairperson Pierson introduced correspondence received as follows: |
| TRI-COUNTY REGIONAL PLANNING COMMISSION REGARDING DECENNIAL CENSUS | Tri-County Regional Planning Commission The importance of The Year 2000 Decennial Census was emphasized. Publicity in positive light in local papers will be pursued by the Administrator. |
| OTTAWA COUNTY RESOLUTION REGARDING COUNTY JAIL REIMBURSEMENT PROGRAM | Ottawa County Resolution urging the State Legislature to amend Public Acts 92 for the County Jail Reimbursement Program so that reimbursement criteria reflects the position of the Michigan Association of Counties and includes (1) Presumptive prison felons, (2) OUIL III felons, and (3) Straddle cell felons who have a Prior Record Variable score of 35 points or more, etc. |
| NATIONWIDE RETIREMENT SOLUTIONS | Nationwide Retirement
Solutions All Financial Services Representatives throughout the country
will be terminated, effective March 31, 2000, with the new model more technology
driven. A Retirement Specialist position will be responsible for group presentations,
seminars and assistance in directing employees in how to enroll and make
changes to their accounts. Individual accounts, on-site changes and offering
advice or service for assets outside the 457 plan will no longer exist.
COMMITTEE RECOMMENDATION: Commissioner Arehart moved, supported by Commissioner Hummel to recommend placing the correspondence on file, with the Ottawa County Resolution being sent to Sheriff Hengesh requesting his comment. Motion carried. BOARD ACTION: Commissioner Pierson moved, supported by Commissioner Arehart to concur with the Committee recommendation. Motion carried. |
| CLINTON TASK FORCE ON EMPLOYMENT REQUESTING BENEFIT CONTINUATION FOR NOREAN SAUL | Chairperson Arehart
introduced correspondence received from Ms. Christine Quinn, Executive Director
for the Clinton Task Force on Employment requesting benefit continuation
for Ms. Norean Saul, Employment Technician.
COMMITTEE RECOMMENDATION: Commissioner Pierson moved, supported by Commissioner Bauerle to recommend that Ms. Norean Saul, Employment Technician, Clinton Task Force on Employment, be allowed to have 108 days worked credited towards the countys health insurance enrollment policy. Motion carried. BOARD ACTION: Commissioner Arehart moved, supported by Commissioner Martin to concur with the Committee recommendation. Motion carried. |
| PLANNING AND ZONING UPDATE REGARDING ZONING ORDINANCE, REZONE ISSUES AND SPECIAL USE PERMITS | Chairperson Pierson
introduced Mr. Gary Webster, Planning and Zoning, regarding a zoning ordinance
update. Proposed language regarding changes to Zoning Districts R-1 and
R-2 were reviewed. The proposed change will be reviewed at a public hearing
in April, 2000 and presented to the Board of Commissioners in May, 2000.
Commissioner Martin requested discussion regarding Motz and Covell rezone issues in Bingham Township. The subdivision control act governs action taken. Timing is of concern to Developer Motz. Commissioner Bauerle requested a report regarding Special Use Permit Annual Inspections. Mr. Webster noted 365 Special Use Permits since 1993, with 347 actual inspections conducted. No action taken. |
| DONALD MALKIN PROPERTY ISSUES | Chairperson Pierson
introduced discussion regarding the Donald Malkin property. A letter was
received from Chief Assistant Prosecutor, Mary Pino, regarding the current
status of the Clinton County Building and Zoning matter on Donald Malkins
property.
Mr. Webster noted that Malkins property has been inspected and he is again collecting junk and rubbish on his premises. He is in violation of the Clinton County Zoning Ordinance. His behavior has not changed. Road kill is also a health issue. The Committee has requested Prosecutor Sherman go to Circuit Court and get an order to be in compliance with the Clinton County Zoning Ordinance. Mr. Webster will talk to Malkins son regarding the cost of hauling away the junk being collected. |
| SHERIFF REQUEST FOR FULL-TIME COURT/SECURITY OFFICER FOR NEW COURTHOUSE | Chairperson Arehart
introduced a request from Sheriff Hengesh for the establishment of a full-time
court/security officer for the new courthouse.
COMMITTEE RECOMMENDATION: Commissioner Pierson moved, supported by Commissioner Rademacher to recommend authorizing the establishment of a full-time court/security officer position within the current allowance of 180 hours, along with funding an estimated $4,539 for additional benefits, to be transferred from Contingency to the Sheriffs 2000 budget. Motion carried. BOARD ACTION: Commissioner Arehart moved, supported by Commissioner Hummel to concur with the Committee recommendation. Motion carried. |
| SHERIFF REQUEST FOR SECURITY STAFFING EQUIPMENT | Chairperson Pierson
introduced discussion regarding security staffing equipment.
COMMITTEE RECOMMENDATION: Commissioner Martin moved, supported by Commissioner Rademacher to recommend funding for security staffing equipment at a cost of $17,460, transferring from Contingency to the Sheriffs 2000 budget. Motion carried. BOARD ACTION: Commissioner Pierson moved, supported by Commissioner Hummel to concur with the Committee recommendation. Motion carried. |
| PARKING ISSUES FOR NEW COURTHOUSE DISCUSSED | Chairperson Pierson introduced discussion regarding parking for the new courthouse. Property adjacent to the Wilson center lot is available for sale. Administration will begin negotiation of a purchase agreement for this property. |
| PUBLIC COMMENTS | Chairperson Pierson requested limited public comments. There were no public comments. |
| ADMINISTRATORS REPORT | Chairperson Pierson
requested an Administrative report. Mr. Wood noted the following:
|
| COMMISSIONERS COMMENTS | Chairperson Pierson
requested Commissioner comments.
|
| FINANCE & PERSONNEL COMMITTEE MEETING | Commissioner Pierson, Finance Chairperson and Commissioner Arehart, Personnel Chairperson reported on a Finance and Personnel Committee meeting held March 23, 2000. |
| AGENDA APPROVED | Chairperson Pierson
called the meeting to order with an addition to the agenda noted.
COMMITTEE ACTION: Commissioner Bauerle moved, supported by Commissioner Martin to approve the agenda as amended. Motion carried. |
| PUBLIC COMMENTS | Chairperson Pierson introduced limited public comments. There were no public comments. |
| ALLEGAN COUNTY RESOLUTION RECEIVED REGARDING RETIREMENT MERS VS ICMA | Chairperson Pierson
introduced a Resolution received from Allegan County regarding Retirement/MERS
vs. ICMA Clarification of Service.
COMMITTEE RECOMMENDATION: Commissioner Arehart moved, supported by Commissioner Rademacher to recommend placing the Allegan County Resolution on file. Motion carried. BOARD ACTION: Commissioner Pierson moved, supported by Commissioner Martin to concur with the Committee recommendation. Motion carried. |
| COMMITTEE MEETING CALENDAR FOR APRIL | Chairperson Pierson introduced the proposed committee meeting calendar for April. The Committee concurred, with one time change made. A revised agenda will be presented at the Board of Commissioners meeting. |
| REGISTER OF DEEDS REQUEST FOR TEMPORARY OFFICE HELP DURING DISABILITY LEAVE OF ABSENCE | Chairperson Arehart
introduced a request from the Register of Deeds office for temporary help
during a disability leave of absence.
COMMITTEE RECOMMENDATION: Commissioner Martin moved, supported by Commissioner Rademacher to recommend authorizing the hiring of a temporary employee for the Register of Deeds office during a disability leave of absence, subject to determining assistance is not available from another department. Motion carried. BOARD ACTION: Commissioner Arehart moved, supported by Commissioner Pierson to concur with the Committee recommendation. Additionally, if it is determined that assistance is not available from another department, the estimated cost of $3,514.00 for the temporary help be taken from contingency. Motion carried. |
| WASTE MANAGEMENT | Chairperson Pierson introduced Ms. Ann Mason, Waste Management Coordinator, regarding the following issues: |
| 2000 LOCAL GRANT PROGRAM | Local Grant Program
- 2000 A summary of project requests were reviewed.
(The DIA requests staff to develop a proposed Buy Recycled Subsidy Fund) COMMITTEE RECOMMENDATION: Commissioner Hummel moved, supported by Commissioner Arehart to recommend awarding project requests for the Local Grant Program 2000 as recommended by the DIA at a cost of $41,002, and also provide a 10% subsidy for all other projects proposing the purchase of recycled content materials at a cost of $4,144, this year only, as a pilot and part of developing a more defined Buy Recycled Subsidy Fund. The total award is $45,646.94. Motion carried. BOARD ACTION: Commissioner Pierson moved, supported by Commissioner Arehart to concur with the Committee recommendation. Motion carried. |
| MODIFICATION OF USER FEE | Modification of the
User Fee Year 2000 has an excess in the fund balance. To be in compliance
with the fund balance policy, we recommend temporarily adjusting the user
fee amount from $.25/cy currently to $.20/cy commencing with Aprils
check for waste received in March. The fee may be re-adjusted at any time
dependent upon fund balance and revenue flow during the year. At maximum,
the adjustment would be in effect only through December 31, 2000.
COMMITTEE RECOMMENDATION: Commissioner Arehart moved, supported by Commissioner Bauerle to recommend a temporary lowering of the User Fee from $.25/cy to $.20/cy commencing with Aprils check for March waste amounts, to be monitored by the Waste Management Coordinator during the year. Motion carried. BOARD ACTION: Commissioner Pierson moved, supported by Commissioner Hummel to concur with the Committee recommendation. Discussion followed. Motion carried. |
| MID-MICHIGAN DISTRICT HEALTH DEPARTMENT DESIRE TO PROCEED WITH RENOVATION OF CLINTON COUNTY OFFICE | Chairperson Pierson
introduced correspondence received from the Mid-Michigan District Health
Department regarding a desire to proceed with the preliminary design for
the renovation of their Clinton County office, requesting approval of a
space allocation study from proposals received.
Mr. Larry Lloyd, Regional Educational Services Agency, spoke regarding the need for a classroom approximately 1,000 square feet in size for vocational education. A Health Alliance class is being offered at Clinton Memorial Hospital and a classroom located at the Service Center would be ideal. The Committee felt it would be helpful to have RESA involved in discussion of plans with the Architect. A Cooperative Agreement between the Health Department and RESA will be brought back to Committee for review at a later date. COMMITTEE RECOMMENDATION: Commissioner Arehart moved, supported by Commissioner Bauerle to recommend authorizing acceptance of the low bid proposal from Hobbs and Black for preliminary space design for the Mid-Michigan District Health Department at a cost not to exceed $3,000, with funds to be transferred from contingency to the Health Department Appropriation. Motion carried. BOARD ACTION: Commissioner Pierson moved, supported by Commissioner Arehart to concur with the Committee recommendation. Discussion followed. Commissioner Pierson noted that the Soil Conservation District has expressed an interest in the building. The Board suggests Soil Conservation make a formal request for consideration. Motion carried. |
| MID-MICHIGAN DISTRICT
HEALTH DEPARTMENT
ACCESS TO CARE GRANTS AVAILABLE |
Chairperson Pierson acknowledged Ms. Singh, Mid-Michigan Health Department Director, regarding Access to Care Grants available. This is to help underinsured and uninsured. There is $25 million available. Ingham County is involved and would like to expand efforts related to access care to Clinton and Eaton Counties. Grant is due June 1, 2000. No action requested. |
| PHYSICAL RESOURCE COMMITTEE REFERRALS | Chairperson Pierson introduced Physical Resource Committee referrals as follows: |
| DRAIN COMMISSIONER FEE SCHEDULE | Drain Commissioner
Fee Schedule The Committee recommends to the Finance and Personnel
Committee adoption of the Fees for Services proposal.
COMMITTEE RECOMMENDATION: Commissioner Arehart moved, supported by Commissioner Bauerle to recommend adoption of the proposed Fees for Services Drain Commissioners Office. Motion carried. BOARD ACTION: Commissioner Pierson moved, supported by Commissioner Arehart to concur with the Committee recommendation. Motion carried. (Insert Fee Schedule) |
| PLANNING AND ZONING ESTABLISHMENT OF A PLANNING DIRECTOR POSITION | Planning and Zoning
The Committee recommends to the Finance and Personnel Committee to
tentatively establish the Planning Director Position as generally outlined
in the job description.
The County Administrator will discuss with Mr. Gary Webster clarification of the delineation between AGS and the County. Completed job descriptions for a County Planner and Secretary will be brought back to committee for review. COMMITTEE RECOMMENDATION: Commissioner Bauerle moved, supported by Commissioner Hummel to recommend the tentative establishment of a County Planner and Secretary position, with experience in Economic Development being desired. Motion carried. BOARD ACTION: Commissioner Pierson moved, supported by Commissioner Arehart to concur with the Committee recommendation. Motion carried. |
| CDBG HOUSING GRANT PROGRAM AWARD BETWEEN MICHIGAN STATE HOUSING DEVELOPMENT AUTHORITY AND CLINTON COUNTY | Chairperson Pierson
introduced discussion regarding the CDBG Housing Grant Program award. The
Administrator updated the Committee regarding the award.
COMMITTEE RECOMMENDATION: Commissioner Rademacher moved, supported by Commissioner Martin to recommend acceptance of Grant agreement (Grant Number MSC-2000-1101-HO) between Michigan State Housing Development Authority and Clinton County as presented, with the Chairperson signing on behalf of the entire Board of Commissioners. Motion carried. BOARD ACTION: Commissioner Pierson moved, supported by Commissioner Hummel to concur with the Committee recommendation. Motion carried. COMMITTEE RECOMMENDATION: Commissioner Martin moved, supported by Commissioner Hummel to recommend the agreement for Grant Administration Services between the City of St. Johns and Clinton County be approved, with the Chairperson signing on behalf of the entire Board of Commissioners. Motion carried. BOARD ACTION: Commissioner Pierson moved, supported by Commissioner Hummel to concur with the Committee recommendation. Motion carried. |
| PUBLIC COMMENTS | Chairperson Pierson requested limited public comments. There were no public comments. |
| ADMINISTRATORS REPORT | Chairperson Pierson
requested the Administrator report as follows:
|
| COMMISSIONERS COMMENTS | Chairperson Pierson
requested Commissioner comments.
|
| BOARD MEETING | |
| APPROVAL OF AUDIT PAYROLL AND GENERAL FUND WEEKLY PAYMENTS | Commissioner Pierson,
Finance Chairperson reported that the audit was conducted with bills totaling
$1,524,351.41 plus payroll of $542,017.06 and general fund weekly bills
totaling $90,009.93 for a grand total of $2,156,378.40.
BOARD ACTION: Commissioner Pierson moved, supported by Commissioner Martin to approve the audit, payroll and general fund weekly bills. Motion carried. |
| RAVE REQUEST FOR LOCAL CERTIFICATION ON APPLICATION TO MSHDA | Chairperson Hawks
introduced a request from RAVE for local certification on their application
to the Michigan State Housing Development Authority. The application is
for continuation of funding for the Clinton County shelter for women and
children who are homeless due to domestic violence.
BOARD ACTION: Commissioner Martin moved, supported by Commissioner Hummel to authorize Chairperson Hawks to sign the local certification for RAVEs application to the MSHDA. Motion carried. |
| ADJOURNMENT | BOARD ACTION:
Commissioner Martin moved, supported by Commissioner Pierson to adjourn.
Motion carried.
______________________________ Diane Zuker, County Clerk NOTE: These minutes are subject to approval on April 25, 2000. |